Sunday, March 26, 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • বাংলা সংস্করণ
Shomporko
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
    • Daily News
    • Feature
    • Sports
  • CANADA
    • Canada Daily
    • Community News
    • Canada Politics
    • Canada Economy
    • Canada Health
  • Global
  • Bangladesh
  • Interview
  • Article
    • Analytical
  • LITERATURE
    • Story
    • Poem
  • Opinion
    • Columnists
  • More
    • Food & Beverage
    • HISTORY
    • Kids Page
    • Travel
    • HOME DECOR
    • Video
    • Social Media
    • Festival
  • Home
  • News
    • Daily News
    • Feature
    • Sports
  • CANADA
    • Canada Daily
    • Community News
    • Canada Politics
    • Canada Economy
    • Canada Health
  • Global
  • Bangladesh
  • Interview
  • Article
    • Analytical
  • LITERATURE
    • Story
    • Poem
  • Opinion
    • Columnists
  • More
    • Food & Beverage
    • HISTORY
    • Kids Page
    • Travel
    • HOME DECOR
    • Video
    • Social Media
    • Festival
No Result
View All Result
Shomporko
No Result
View All Result
Home Article

WHAT WOULD YOU DO?

by Shomporko Online News Desk
March 31, 2021
in Article
0
WHAT WOULD YOU DO?
0
SHARES
95
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Soren Paul Petrek

About the writer: Soren Petrek is a practicing criminal trial attorney, admitted to the Minnesota Bar in 1991. Soren’s novel, Cold Lonely Courage won Fade In Magazine’s 2009 Award for Fiction. Fade In was voted the nation’s favourite movie magazine by the Washington Post and the L.A. Times in 2011 and 2012. Soren is represented by Tiziana Marzano international literary agent.

As a criminal defense attorney, I appeal cases on behalf of defendants who were represented by alternate counsel at trial. On appeal, one is limited to the trial record, the law and the actions and decisions of the prosecution and defense counsel. Questions regarding jury’s decision based upon the evidence presented are questions of fact and rarely disturbed by reviewing courts. Questions regarding law depend upon the decisions of the trial court and the status of the law in the jurisdiction.

When a law is vague or confusing to the detriment of the defendant, their right to a fair trial can be fatally impacted. Jury instructions or statements of the law given to the jury by the trial court are prime examples.

I have a case on appeal to the Minnesota Supreme court involving a minority, immigrant defendant. He was convicted of soliciting a minor prostitute for sex using electronic means. Law enforcement set up a sting operation and entrapped him into committing the various elements of the offense via text message. A jury convicted him, his appeal to the Minnesota court of appeals was denied and now the Minnesota supreme Court must decide if the jury instructions promulgated by the trial court were vague or otherwise legally deficient.

At least half of the states in the USA require the jury instruction on entrapment to state that: 1. The defendant must prove by a preponderance, more likely than not, that he was induced by the government to commit the offense for which he’s charged. If so, then the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt, our highest standard, that the defendant was predisposed to commit the crime. These two standards are the opposite ends of the evidentiary spectrum, lowest to highest.

The Minnesota Jury Instruction Guide does not require that the jury instruction on entrapment state the defendant’s burden of proof and the state’s burden of proof separately. Failing to do so is confusing. What standard of proof is the jury to apply to the defendant’s evidence? If you were a juror, without direction by the judge, what would you do? In my opinion, one would apply the only standard that is provided, beyond a reasonable doubt. That would be improper, unfairly burdensome on the defendant and unconstitutional.
Keep in mind that a disproportionate number of defendants are minorities and do not have the resources to afford private counsel and have to rely upon court appointed counsel with massive caseloads and inadequate resources when compared to the prosecutions juggernaut power, influence, and money.

Without leveling the playing field, there is no equity nor right to a fair trial. At least, the trial court judge’s instructions to the finder of fact, the jurors, should be free of confusing, misleading, missing, and inaccurate language. Failing to safeguard a defendant’s rights leads to disastrous verdicts and in my client’s case easily remedied.

Previous Post

Toronto restaurants struggling to enforce one-household dining rule

Next Post

Use of AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine in younger adults

Shomporko Online News Desk

Related Posts

Rebuffing ransomware: How to prevent your organization from becoming a victim
Article

Rebuffing ransomware: How to prevent your organization from becoming a victim

December 8, 2021
What is the midlife crisis? It is nothing but an emotional crisis of identity and self-confidence that can occur in early middle age. And what is middle age?
Article

What is the midlife crisis? It is nothing but an emotional crisis of identity and self-confidence that can occur in early middle age. And what is middle age?

October 8, 2021
Black Hole Swallows a Neutron
Article

Black Hole Swallows a Neutron

July 11, 2021
BE POSITIVE
Article

BE POSITIVE

April 27, 2021
Autoimmune Disease in Children
Article

Autoimmune Disease in Children

February 24, 2021
DYING GASP
Article

THE PHOTOGRAPHER

February 9, 2021
Next Post

Use of AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine in younger adults

Logo

Disclaimer:

The editorial team is not responsible for the content of the writing.

Publisher and Editor
Sonia Hoque

General Manager

Rewrite-Man

Reporter

Graphics
Mozammel Sarkar

Address:

Shomporko Magazine

59 Byng ave
Scarborough,
Ontario
M1L3N8

Phone :647-686-5432

 

Email: 
shomporko.magazine@gmail.com
2537765 Ontario Ltd

© 2020 Shomporko – Magazine Develop by RMITtech

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • NEWS
    • Daily News
    • Feature
    • Global
    • Politics
    • Sports
  • CANADA
    • Canada Daily
    • Community News
    • Canada Politics
    • Canada Economy
    • Canada Immigration
    • Canada Education
    • Canada Health
    • Canada Opinion
  • GLOBAL
  • INTERVIEW
  • ARTICLE
    • Analytical
  • LITERATURE
    • Story
    • Poem
  • OPINION
    • Opinion
    • Columnists
    • Legal Advice
  • ARTS
    • Home Decor
    • Sports
  • LIVING
    • Health
    • Food
    • Travel
    • HISTORY
    • Kids Page
  • MORE
    • Video
    • Social Media
    • Festival
  • বাংলা সংস্করণ

© 2019 Shomporko - Magazine Develop by RMITtech.

Translate »